When it comes to diagnosing injuries involving joints, ligaments, tendons, and muscles, the difference between a general radiologist and a musculoskeletal (MSK) subspecialist can be life-changing. At MDView, we’ve seen firsthand how second opinions from MSK-trained radiologists have prevented unnecessary surgeries, reduced recovery times, and helped patients regain confidence in their care.

An Orthopedist's Review vs your Radiology Reports

Many orthopedic diagnoses rely heavily on imaging - MRIs, CTs, and X-rays - to determine the course of treatment. When it comes to musculoskeletal (MSK) imaging, not all radiology reports are created equal - and not all orthopedic surgeons rely on them. Studies show that orthopedic surgeons often disagree with radiology reports, particularly those written by general radiologists. In fact, a survey of orthopedic surgeons in Australia and New Zealand revealed that 55% reported disagreements with MRI interpretations, and only 18.5% said they always reviewed formal radiology reports. Another study across orthopedic departments in Europe found that 20% of surgeons never consulted plain radiograph reports at all. Reasons cited included delays in report availability, lack of time, and overly lengthy reports. This variability in review and trust underscores a critical point: without a second opinion from a subspecialized MSK radiologist, your diagnosis could be based on a radiology report that was either incomplete - or even dismissed. Getting a second opinion ensures your images are reviewed by someone with deep expertise in MSK imaging, potentially changing your diagnosis and your treatment path entirely.

The High Cost of Misdiagnosis

Unfortunately, many studies have shows that in musculoskeletal surgery cases, many patients undergo more procedures than necessary. Studies have shown that around 50% of lumbar spine surgeries and 35% of knee replacement surgeries may be unnecessary, just to name a few. These surgeries are costing the U.S. healthcare system billions annually and putting patients at risk of complications, extended recovery, and emotional stress (Forbes - 2023)

Why Subspecialization Matters

Radiologists who specialize in musculoskeletal imaging undergo additional fellowship training focused solely on bones, joints, and soft tissues. They are not only better equipped to detect subtle injuries but also less likely to over-call findings that appear severe to a generalist.

A recent study found significant discrepancies in interpretations between general radiologists and MSK specialists. In over 26% of cases, the MSK radiologist's report led to a change in clinical management (American Journal of Roentgenology - 2016). These aren’t just academic differences - these are changes that can prevent patients from undergoing unnecessary surgeries.

An MDView Lifechanging Outcome: Ecaterina B.

Ecaterina B. was told she had a Grade 3 tear of the superior surface of the posterior horn of the medial meniscus - a severe injury that typically requires surgery and a structured 3 to 6-month rehabilitation program. The diagnosis was overwhelming. Faced with the prospect of surgery and months away from her active lifestyle, Ecaterina turned to MDView for a second opinion.

Her second opinion was conducted by Dr. Goldstein, a board-certified, fellowship-trained musculoskeletal radiologist. His findings? A possible small horizontal tear - a much less severe injury that could often be managed conservatively with physical therapy and rest.

The difference between the two findings is significant:

• A Grade 3 tear suggests a complete disruption of the meniscal tissue, with symptoms like locking, instability, and a high likelihood of requiring surgical intervention.

• A small horizontal tear, particularly if asymptomatic or mild, often heals with non-surgical treatment and doesn't necessitate a lengthy recovery.

Thanks to the accuracy and specialization of Dr. Goldstein's report, Ecaterina avoided an unnecessary procedure.

"I’m beyond grateful for MDView and for Dr. Goldstein. His second opinion not only gave me peace of mind, it saved me from going through a completely unnecessary surgery. I feel empowered and informed, and I’m back to moving pain-free!"
— Ecaterina B.

The Bottom Line

Getting a second opinion from a subspecialized musculoskeletal radiologist can be the difference between surgery and a simple recovery plan. As imaging is the foundation to nearly all medical decision-making, the accuracy of those interpretations must be held to the highest standard.

At MDView, we ensure your scans are reviewed by the right expert for your exact condition—so your care plan is based on precision, not assumption. Have your musculoskeletal radiology imaging exam reviewed by an expert MSK radiologist today.

Don't have your exam? No problem! MDView can get your images from the facility at no cost! Just register for an account and complete the Have MDView Get My Exam form today. https://app.mdview.com